Simple Simon's Pizza Reviews
Simple Simon's Pizza has an overall rating of 4.4 based on 102 reviews. Customer feedback on Simple Simon's Pizza is mixed: Simple Simon's Pizza reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious pizza, friendly staff, quick service and great value for money, which strongly appeal to families, pizza lovers, local residents and casual diners. However, Simple Simon's Pizza is often criticized for its limited menu options, inconsistent quality, long wait times and occasional delivery issues.
102 reviews
5 Stars
12
4 Stars
5
3 Stars
2
2 Stars
1
1 Star
0
How would you rate Simple Simon's Pizza?
All Simple Simon's Pizza Reviews (102)
ellen_Nielsen93
May 18, 2026
"Decent spot, but the dirty tables were annoying"
It was an okay place overall, nothing too bad, but the dining area definitely could’ve used more attention. A few tables needed wiping, which was kind of annoying when you’re trying to sit down and eat. Not terrible, just not as clean as I’d hoped.
0
Reply
RosemaryFlores_07
May 11, 2026
"The box was nice and sturdy, and..."
The box was nice and sturdy, and there weren’t really any leaks or anything. Everything seemed packed good overall
0
Reply
delores1997
May 09, 2026
"Ordering took like two minutes"
I ordered through simplesimonspizza.com it was super easy. The menu loaded right away, adding things to the cart actually made sense, and checkout didn’t feel like a whole life event. I really liked being able to see my total before paying too. No weird steps, no confusing pages, just quick and painless. Got my order placed in no time, so yeah, easy 5 stars from me.
0
Reply
thomassmith0747
May 02, 2026
"I like the pizza overall, and..."
I like the pizza overall, and if I’m picking it up, I don’t really have any complaints. The only frustrating part is the delivery area. My place shows as outside the range even though I’m not that far from the store, so it feels a bit confusing. I get that delivery zones have to have limits, but I do wish they covered a little more of town.
0
Reply
Ida_vaughn91
April 17, 2026
"Really nice customer service"
Had a good experience with the customer service at Simple Simon’s Pizza. I just had a quick little question about my order, nothing major, and they got back to me fast without making it feel like a hassle.
The person I talked to was friendly and just seemed like they actually wanted to help, which isn’t always the case these days. So yeah, I appreciated that a lot
The person I talked to was friendly and just seemed like they actually wanted to help, which isn’t always the case these days. So yeah, I appreciated that a lot
0
Reply
Kathleen_hoke86
April 04, 2026
"Really good specialty pizza options"
I really liked the specialty pizza choices here. The chicken bacon ranch one was my favorite, anything with bacon is usually a win for me, but this one was especially good.
0
Reply
chiquita-Ragland
April 02, 2026
"I wish I’d realized how convenient this Simple..."
I wish I’d realized how convenient this Simple Simon’s was a while ago. It’s super easy for me to swing by after work, and I haven’t had any trouble with parking so far. Makes grabbing pizza really quick without having to go out of my way
0
Reply
JuanBlackmon
March 26, 2026
"Nice relaxed spot for a quick pizza"
I stopped in with my family and the place had a chill vibe. It wasn’t too loud, but there was still sorta that nice buzz of people eating and chatting.
The tables were clean and the lighting felt warm enough, nothing fancy, just comfortable. It seemed like an easy place to sit down for a bit and enjoy a quick pizza without feeling rushed.
I’d probably give it 4 stars just because the front area was sorta crowded, so it was a little awkward moving around. Other than that, the atmosphere was good and I’d go back.
The tables were clean and the lighting felt warm enough, nothing fancy, just comfortable. It seemed like an easy place to sit down for a bit and enjoy a quick pizza without feeling rushed.
I’d probably give it 4 stars just because the front area was sorta crowded, so it was a little awkward moving around. Other than that, the atmosphere was good and I’d go back.
0
Reply
kris-Moss
March 26, 2026
"Super easy parking"
So... I was able to park right out front, which made it super easy to run in and grab my pizza quickly.
0
Reply
HerbertJantz
March 12, 2026
"Really good pizza for around the price"
I’ve ordered from Simple Simons about a few times now, and it’s been solid every time. The pizzas are a good size, taste fresh, and don’t feel overpriced at all. For what you pay, it’s hard to complain
0
Reply
ThomasRose_34
February 28, 2026
"Solid lunch buffet, would go back"
Stopped in for the lunch buffet and thought it was a good deal. The pizza was hot, the salad bar looked clean, and they kept bringing out fresh stuff so it never felt like we were just picking through leftovers.
The staff was friendly and checked in just enough without hovering. My only small thing was that a couple of the pizzas disappeared fast, but they did replace them quickly. Did anyone else have that happen during lunch? Either way, it’s a solid spot when you want a quick pizza lunch and don’t feel like waiting.
The staff was friendly and checked in just enough without hovering. My only small thing was that a couple of the pizzas disappeared fast, but they did replace them quickly. Did anyone else have that happen during lunch? Either way, it’s a solid spot when you want a quick pizza lunch and don’t feel like waiting.
0
Reply
hello_michael736
February 23, 2026
"Decent pizza, but really slow"
The pizza itself was okay, so I don’t want to sound too harsh, but the timing has been frustrating. I ordered pickup once and it took way longer than they told me, and then I tried delivery another time and that was late too. Maybe I just caught them on bad days, but I’m wondering if other people have had the same experience. Not terrible overall, just really slow.
0
Reply
Frances_trevino96
February 07, 2026
"Really Good Pizza"
The pizza was really good, like really good. The crust was nice, the toppings tasted fresh, and it was just an easy, satisfying meal. I’d definitely get it again.
0
Reply
rodolfo2001
February 05, 2026
"They actually got everything right"
I was expecting to find something missing because I was in a rush and probably didn’t even double-check the order that well, but everything was there and correct this time. No complaints from me...
0
Reply
HermanHall_65
January 13, 2026
"Consistent From Location to Location"
Not gonna lie, I’ve tried a few different locations and the pizza has been consistent every time. The service can vary a bit depending on who’s working, but overall it’s been a solid experience.
0
Reply
theresasmith2060
January 05, 2026
"Made ordering so much easier for my allergy-picky family"
My family can be picky, especially with allergies, so clear allergy info makes a huge difference. It was easy to find what we needed and order without stressing the whole time. It just feels like the decent thing for places to do, and I really appreciated it...
0
Reply
KariConrad
December 26, 2025
"Easy pizza after work"
I really like that their hours are easy to find, and they’re usually still open when I’m getting off work. Long day. Tired. Ordered pizza without any hassle, and it was exactly what I needed.
0
Reply
RubenCrawford_07
December 24, 2025
"Stopped in with my kids, and I..."
Stopped in with my kids, and I was relieved there were plenty of seats right away. When places are packed, I always feel kind of trapped trying to keep everyone together and find somewhere to sit, so it was nice not dealing with that. We didn’t have to wait or squeeze in anywhere, and the tables were clean too. Just an easy, low-stress pizza stop for us.
0
Reply
hello_dan992
December 17, 2025
"I was happy with how many options..."
I was happy with how many options were on the menu—there really seemed to be something for everyone. Then I got a little bummed because I wish they had more side options to choose from. Still, overall it was a good experience and I’d go back.
0
Reply
bruno_Turner79
December 06, 2025
"Great for a family of picky eaters"
I really like how easy it is to switch up the toppings and make everyone happy. In my house, one person wants extra cheese, another wants no onions, someone else wants pepperoni, and then there’s always one who suddenly decides they only want plain cheese. So being able to customize things without a hassle is a big plus. Ordering was simple too, though I did take a while deciding between toppings, sizes, crust, sauces, and all that, but that was more my problem than anything else. Overall, it’s a solid 4 stars from me.
0
Reply
Have a question about Simple Simon's Pizza?
Log in to ask your Simple Simon's Pizza question!
Popular Brands
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
